You ask how I am
and I say ‘fine’
I ask how you’re doing
and you say ‘well’
then we cling to the threads
of other people’s lives
on opposite sides
of a room
much smaller
for the clouds now moving in
and though we never broached the weather
I think it’s going to rain
tonight.
Isobel,
yOUR REASON FOR KEEPING IT AS IS ARE
SOUND.
Another new one! On a roooolllll!
Clever, succinct, very different from previous form. Good poem - enjoyed.
Took me years of self-tuition to learn small talk, as it goes. Couldn't understand how people opened their mouths and said...nothing.
for the clouds now moving in - I'd have preferred summat clearer, simpler
now the clouds are moving in
I liked the poem, nice title.
Isobel, you know what I would say. Don't change it.
As for paring it there is some fat but in the hesitant atmosphere of the situation here, one can often overuse words in a nervous sort of way, ergo leave the fat in.
I like this style for you.
best wishes, Graham.
Thank you Harry - your suggestions work well also.
I wanted to stick with 'on opposite sides' cos I think it infers better the deliberate positioning one might make to avoid an awkward social situation - also the gulf that can open up between two people.
You've put your finger on the one part of the poem I agonised over - the positioning of that 'now' :) I can hear what you are saying but I'm starting to wonder if the poem is not just stronger taking the word out - I suppose the now is implicit and it does ruin the flow a bit. Oh the agonies of poetry - a lot of people would think this a simple poem - but I did spend some time thinking about it LOL.
Isobel,
Excellent example of less saying more with delicate restraint...and what a perfect ending.
It`s so good I`m tempted: (lines 7,8,9,10...)
What if they read:
from opposite sides
of a room
now much smaller
for the clouds moving in
But I suggest very hesitantly
(I agree, it`s not your usual style)
darren thomas
Mon 5th Nov 2012 17:11
An obvious change in style from this to, say... Chlamydia?
I enjoy poetry like this. You leave enough room for a reader.
Hi Isobel, really enjoyed this. Conveys so much without actually saying it out loud. Thanks for sharing. T.
The most important words in this poem are those you so eloquently don't use. :)
Regards,
A.E. x
Beautifully said - love it - completely : )
This is a fine poem, Isobel, that says a hell of a lot in just a few lines. That thing about the weather is clever, too.
Thanks for your comments everyone.
Yes Chris, I could probably have made it sparser and made a neater point about small talk. I don't think I could have made it sparser and also got across the mood and mental images I wanted to create though.
Cathy's comment says it all for me, in not many words - huge small talk. :)
I was surprised by the relative sparseness of the language. Sparse-ish short-ish, neat, implied yet accessible.
Good to confound expectations with differing styles now and then. Far more interesting than a certain red wheelbarrow imo.
Could the poem be tighter, truly sparse and still retain its essence? I think it could, with some work. But either way - Enjoyable -
Best
Chris
It reminds me of the final verse of Bob Dylan's Desolation Row.
"Yes, I received your letter yesterday
About the time that the door-knob
broke
Then you ask me how I'm doing,
Is that some kind of joke?"
It's what Paul Simon called "The Dangling Conversation".
steve mellor
Sun 4th Nov 2012 11:31
'Like' is probably the wrong word, but I do find it a painfully accurate reflection of the lives of many people.
How does one get past the minutae, into a more meaningful discussion/relationship?
Who takes the first step, or are both sides of the conversation culpable?
Huge small talk x
If you wish to post a comment you must login.
This site uses only functional cookies that are essential to the operation of the site. We do not use cookies related to advertising or tracking. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.
Ged Thompson
Sun 23rd Dec 2012 01:59
I love you and your poem XXXXX