A Centenary War Poem for my father Bill Baine (1899-1968)
A CENTENARY WAR POEM
for Bill Baine, 1899-1968
‘What passing-bells for those who die as cattle?
Only the monstrous anger of the guns.’
And so some lines to spike centenary prattle:
These words a sole survivor soldier’s son’s.
My father Bill, born in Victorian England:
The sixth of January, 1899.
His stock, loyal London. Proletarian doff-cap.
Aged seventeen, he went to join the line.
Not in a war to end all wars forever
Just in a ghastly slaughter at the Somme -
A pointless feud, a royal family squabble
Fought by their proxy poor with gun and bomb.
My father saved. Pyrexia, unknown origin.
Front line battalion: he lay sick in bed.
His comrades formed their line, then came the whistle
And then the news that every one was dead.
In later life a polished comic poet
No words to us expressed that awful fear
Although we knew such things were not forgotten.
He dreamed Sassoon: he wrote Belloc and Lear.
When I was ten he died, but I remember,
Although just once, he’d hinted at the truth.
He put down Henry King and Jabberwocky
And read me Owen’s ‘Anthem For Doomed Youth’.
‘What passing-bells for those who die as cattle?
Only the monstrous anger of the guns.’
And so some lines to spike Gove’s mindless prattle:
These words a sole survivor soldier’s son’s.
John F Keane
Sun 26th Jan 2014 18:05
A lot of these issues are very complex. Rather than the generals being incompetent, military technology at that time made attacking very difficult. The same was true of the American Civil War. Pickett's Charge at Gettysburg was very similar to the Somme, and for the same reasons. And at the end of the Civil War, both sides were fighting in trenches around Richmond, just like WW1. Unfortunately, Europeans did not learn the lessons of the Civil War on either side. They imagined WW1 was going to be Napoleonic. Many Civil War generals thought that too, until they learned better.