Donations are essential to keep Write Out Loud going    

Profile image

Cynthia Buell Thomas

Tue 21st Jun 2011 10:45

This is really good, Laura, a fine example of haiku. The whole series develops a theme, but each 'stanza' could stand alone, is wholly sufficient on to itself. I look forward to meeting you in Sale next Tuesday.

Comment is about Ring of Roses (blog)

Original item by Laura Taylor

Profile image

shoeless

Tue 21st Jun 2011 10:40

thanks for your insightful comment on my poem gus , missing your hugs right now x x

Comment is about Gus Jonsson (poet profile)

Original item by Gus Jonsson

Profile image

shoeless

Tue 21st Jun 2011 10:39

thanks for commenting on my poem dave :)

Comment is about Dave Bradley (poet profile)

Original item by Dave Bradley

Profile image

Alan Morrison

Tue 21st Jun 2011 10:31

Sigh... there you go again. Saying what needs to be said with such economy and poise. The more you do it (like peeling away the layers of an onion), the more I understand you. The more I understand you, the more I respect you. You are the essence of what poetry should be...

Comment is about Daddys girl (blog)

Original item by Kath Hewitt

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Tue 21st Jun 2011 09:18

You brought this to life at Cadence. Whenever I hear you speak your poems, you always do.

Comment is about Leaving Belfast (blog)

Original item by Andy N

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Tue 21st Jun 2011 09:17

Thanks for your note on Ring of Roses, Andy - appreciate it

Comment is about Andy N (poet profile)

Original item by Andy N

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Tue 21st Jun 2011 09:15

Thanks for your note on Ring of Roses Cate :) I actually love dead flowers, heh.

Comment is about Cate (poet profile)

Original item by Cate

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Tue 21st Jun 2011 09:04

Oh Kath - this is heartbreaking, in its message and its childlike simplicity. I feel like sometimes I am watching you strip your skin raw with these pieces.

Comment is about Daddys girl (blog)

Original item by Kath Hewitt

Profile image

Andy N

Tue 21st Jun 2011 08:17

it's a interesting one, alison must admit following on from the comments. i like the structure behind it certainly even thou it is a bit preachy for me in places, but certainly there is scope for edits to make it even better.

look forward to seeing what you do next with it certo. x

Comment is about Optimism (blog)

Original item by Alison Smiles

Profile image

Andy N

Tue 21st Jun 2011 08:15

very sharp stuff, Laura.. lot of detail in a few words here.. impressive x

Comment is about Ring of Roses (blog)

Original item by Laura Taylor

<Deleted User> (7075)

Mon 20th Jun 2011 23:01

Hi Charlotte, welcome to Write out loud. Winston

Comment is about Charlotte Peters Rock (poet profile)

Original item by Charlotte Peters Rock

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Mon 20th Jun 2011 21:13

Hi Laura, what an interesting piece! Yes it is tagged haiku, Dave must have just missed it.
Floral deviance and beauty in decay wouldnt be my idea of a bunch of flowers, but after seeing the winning garden of the Chelsea flower show which looked just like the field across the road from me, who knows?
I like the spareness here which makes every word count. Clever title too!
Cate xx

Comment is about Ring of Roses (blog)

Original item by Laura Taylor

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Mon 20th Jun 2011 21:03

A vivid and powerful piece of writing. Very touching.
Cate xx

Comment is about The Care Pathway For The Dying Phase (blog)

Profile image

Isobel

Mon 20th Jun 2011 20:09

Crumbs - you don't get much sadder than this - my idea of living hell brought to life so hideously by your poem. It brought back horrid memories for me too...

The positive and chirpy nature of the medical staff often seem so incongruous when you know just what is going down. I suppose they have to develop that protective shell though, or they wouldn't be able to do the job.

I would agree with Andy N on that line 'colouring in the silence' is a great metaphor.

Glug - something for us all to look forward to.

Comment is about The Care Pathway For The Dying Phase (blog)

Profile image

Isobel

Mon 20th Jun 2011 19:57

'Or even offer food for thought' - I'm not sure I'd agree with that Alison - your poem seems to have stirred feelings up in its readers.

You are right to say that poetry can't change anything - it's hard enough for individuals to do that. It does enable like minded people to connect though - which in some circumstances can be pretty marvellous.

I would agree with Julian's comments. The poem is so strong and could be even stronger just by a bit of trimming. I really enjoyed reading this. x

Comment is about Optimism (blog)

Original item by Alison Smiles

Profile image

Julian (Admin)

Mon 20th Jun 2011 19:03

This poem has the potential to be a powerful classic, along the lines of, as Laura says, The Revolution will not be televised. It puts me mind, too, of Adrian Mitchell's poem whose title I forget but is more generally known by its repeating line, "tell me lies about Vietnam".
I - cheekily, I know, as it's your poem - would think about removing anything adverbial from it (e.g. 'even', 'just') and any forced rhymes (cease/decrease) as these IMHO reduce its power. Inspiring, Alison, truly. Don't leave it like this.

Comment is about Optimism (blog)

Original item by Alison Smiles

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Mon 20th Jun 2011 15:58

It really does work on the page, and I wasn't sure it would you know. Fantastic! Really looking forward to reading and hearing more of your work.

Comment is about Jess Green (poet profile)

Original item by Jess Green

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Mon 20th Jun 2011 15:49

Japanese? Interesting! Cheers Dave.

Err, it already IS tagged as a haiku. Is it not showing or something?

Comment is about Ring of Roses (blog)

Original item by Laura Taylor

Profile image

alisonsmiles68@gmail.com

Mon 20th Jun 2011 15:49

Eeeek, can't even blame predictive text for that. I shall edit.

Comment is about Optimism (blog)

Original item by Alison Smiles

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Mon 20th Jun 2011 15:47

Yeh, I like what it's saying too - had a feeling of The Revolution Will Not Be Televised about it, in the rhythm.

Comment is about Optimism (blog)

Original item by Alison Smiles

Profile image

Dave Bradley

Mon 20th Jun 2011 13:53

Any poem about a physical object which makes one really SEE and FEEL it is working well, and this does - vividly. But it's not just about the object, it's about the passing of time. It almost feels Japanese in the way that it expresses this.

Will you be tagging it as a haiku?

Comment is about Ring of Roses (blog)

Original item by Laura Taylor

Profile image

Dave Bradley

Mon 20th Jun 2011 13:43

I really love what this poem is saying, Alison and like the way it's being said too.

Is omissions a typo? (sorry)

Comment is about Optimism (blog)

Original item by Alison Smiles

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Mon 20th Jun 2011 09:59

CC is one of my favourite books. See the cat? See the cradle? Brilliant.

Love this Dave - I have actually tried this, just to see what it felt like. It's really bloody awkward to get in position :D

Comment is about boko-maru haiku (blog)

Original item by Dave Bradley

Profile image

Laura Taylor

Mon 20th Jun 2011 09:57

Heartbreaking, and really well written. Good one Ray

Comment is about The Care Pathway For The Dying Phase (blog)

Profile image

Andy N

Mon 20th Jun 2011 08:18

love it, kath.. another excellent piece.

one little thing perhaps on the last line you may want to add an even 'sometimes i don't even get to choose' as i am wondering whether it needs the extra word.

otherwise, keep em coming x

Comment is about No title (blog)

Original item by Kath Hewitt

Profile image

Andy N

Mon 20th Jun 2011 08:18

love it, kath.. another excellent piece.

one little thing perhaps on the last line you may want to add an even 'sometimes i don't even get to choose' as i am wondering whether it needs the extra word.

otherwise, keep em coming x

Comment is about No title (blog)

Original item by Kath Hewitt

Profile image

Andy N

Mon 20th Jun 2011 08:14

nice stuff, dave... see you soon - a

Comment is about boko-maru haiku (blog)

Original item by Dave Bradley

Profile image

Andy N

Mon 20th Jun 2011 08:13

good piece, Ray - particularly like 'colouring in the silence'... A

Comment is about The Care Pathway For The Dying Phase (blog)

Profile image

Fkx

Mon 20th Jun 2011 00:35

Indeed, I would love to see this piece performed. Must admit I found it a bit hard to get past the lines on 'loo seat' and 'milestone.' I will read that aloud again and change my pace and see if that makes any difference. I learned a new thing as well - that Dettol and Dettox is one and the same thing!

Comment is about Dear Mr Dettol. Fact. (blog)

Philipos

Sun 19th Jun 2011 22:17

Hi Ann so glad you found the John Donne poem informative and to your liking - I happened to be passing an old haunt of his near Pyrford in Surrey today when walking with my daughter by the canal hence the inspiration

Comment is about Ann Foxglove (poet profile)

Original item by Ann Foxglove

Adam Woolley

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:41

Thank you Ann for taking the time to read my blogs, and for your comment. It really is much appreciated! :)

Comment is about Ann Foxglove (poet profile)

Original item by Ann Foxglove

Profile image

Andy N

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:24

thanks for the comment, katy lisa.. glad you liked it.. x

Comment is about Spring is here (blog)

Original item by Andy N

Profile image

Andy N

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:24

thanks for the comment, katy lisa.. is a bit of a odd piece this one, must admit and i agree with you - it's certainly a spooky one x

Comment is about Lost Shadows (blog)

Original item by Andy N

Profile image

Andy N

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:23

thanks katy lisa - glad you liked it - you know already my answer to your comment here - lol x

Comment is about Escape (blog)

Original item by Andy N

Profile image

Andy N

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:23

thanks for the comment, katy lisa here.. i totally agree with you over this piece and am glad you enjoyed it xx

Comment is about Summer is Here (blog)

Original item by Andy N

Profile image

Andy N

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:22

thanks ann for your comment on leaving belfast, ann. belfast is a place i certainly won't forget, i must admit and am glad you enjoyed this piece.. x

Comment is about Ann Foxglove (poet profile)

Original item by Ann Foxglove

Profile image

Andy N

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:21

thanks katy lisa and ann for your comments.. belfast is a place i certainly won't forget, i must admit and am glad you enjoyed this piece.. x

Comment is about Leaving Belfast (blog)

Original item by Andy N

<Deleted User> (7212)

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:07

Cate - Many thanks for taking the time to comment (mackerel sky). B

Comment is about Cate (poet profile)

Original item by Cate

<Deleted User> (7212)

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:06

Ann - Many thanks for taking the time to comment (mackerel sky). B

Comment is about Ann Foxglove (poet profile)

Original item by Ann Foxglove

<Deleted User> (7212)

Sun 19th Jun 2011 21:06

Dave - Many thanks for taking the time to comment (mackerel sky). B

Comment is about Dave Bradley (poet profile)

Original item by Dave Bradley

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Sun 19th Jun 2011 20:00

There is some arresting imagery in this Emma, and phrases which linger in the mind like"cats cradling her thoughts."
As to the direction it should go since each stanza is about a different character maybe a final summing up of the whole idea of loneliness and silence would work?
Cate xx

Comment is about SOFT FOCUSED SILENCE (blog)

Original item by Emma McCourty

Philipos

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:58

Hi Val thank you for comenting on my John Donne poem - having studied the man in some depth I found his age a fascinating one even though I wouldn't want to have lived then - did a walk with my daughter today along a Surrey canal near Pyrford where there was a plaque commemorating his place of residence in the 1600s hence my motivation to write about him

Comment is about Valerie Cook (poet profile)

Original item by Valerie Cook

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:43

I really liked this Dave, a change from your performance humorous ones but effective in a simple way.
Cate xx

Comment is about Every cloud (blog)

Original item by Dave Carr

Profile image

Julian (Admin)

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:35

Magnificent Ray: observant, humane, essential, spare.

Comment is about The Care Pathway For The Dying Phase (blog)

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:18

Clever and very sweet. Not sure it would do it for me though!
Cate xx

Comment is about boko-maru haiku (blog)

Original item by Dave Bradley

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:06

Hi Emma thanks for your comment on Naughty Digits... glad you enjoyed it!
Cate xx

Comment is about Emma McCourty (poet profile)

Original item by Emma McCourty

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:04

Hi Laura thanks for the comment on Naughty Digits, and for the editing... much appreciated!!
Cate xx

Comment is about Laura Taylor (poet profile)

Original item by Laura Taylor

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:02

Hi Dave thanks for the comment on Naughty digits.... I do believe he did!!
Cate xx

Comment is about Dave Carr (poet profile)

Original item by Dave Carr

Profile image

Cate Greenlees

Sun 19th Jun 2011 19:01

Hi Dave, thanks for the comment.... not sure about the performance bit!!!!!
Cate xx

Comment is about Dave Bradley (poet profile)

Original item by Dave Bradley

Profile image

winston plowes

Sun 19th Jun 2011 16:27

Hi Tom, Can you send me details of Bob's upcoming gigs please, H x

Comment is about Laura Taylor (poet profile)

Original item by Laura Taylor

More Comments

◄ Prev123 … 299 … 598 … 897 … 1196 … 1495 … 1794 … 2093 … 2392 … 24302431243224332434 … 2691 … 298629872988Next ►

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Find out more Hide this message